GermaNet Adjectives Partially Cleaned Up - Polar Properties

In the previous post, I shared an adjective classification scheme from the GermaNet project. I don't think it's very good, but I think it's good that someone made some data available. There are so many adjective taxonomies reported in the literature that you just can't find/access/download/read. It's good that GermaNet's adjective supersense taxonomy exists, but I want to do better. 

I've sorted large lists of adjectives a few times in my life. I intend to go through through some of the results of that work and compare them, synthesize, figure it all out once and for all. At the very least I intend to figure it all out for a restricted set of adjectives - the ones that have opposites and that have noun forms, i.e. the polar properties. In English, adjective words often turn into property nouns by adding -ness or -ence/-ance, or -ity. You know the ones.

Anyway, I tried cleaning up the GermaNet adjective categories, to make it more like a taxonomy of Polar Properties. I ended up adding and deleting quite a few adjectives. It's fairly loosely related to the original at this point, but the result is still more like GermaNet than something I would have come up with on my own. 

I haven't removed every adjective that doesn't have a noun form (though I've mostly marked these with exclamation marks). And I've left in a few adjective clusters that are categorical instead of binary (which I've mostly marked with multiple vertical pipe symbols). But I'm posting it anyway because I feel that my edits have produced a fairly clear conside readable taxonomy, and I wanted to show what I think the GermaNet adjective categories could have looked like with a little more organization.

-

* Behavior > Abstract:
inclusive | exclusive
productive | unproductive
sensitive | insensitive

* Behavior > Dynamical:
concrete/hard/rigid/firm | soft/flimsy/flexible
  solid | fluid
slippery / grippy
steady | unsteady
strong/sturdy/stout | weak
powerful/effective | ineffective/feeble/impotent
immobile/stationary/idle/inactive | mobile/active/busy
volatile | stable
ephemeral | permanent
rapid/quick/fast | slow
sudden | gradual
frequent | infrequent/rare

* Substance, Composition, Chemical Properties:
basic/alkaline | acidic
ionic | anionic
wet | moist/humid/damp | dry/arid
heavy | lightweight
clean | dirty
pure | impure
heterogeneous | uniform/homogeneous
?natural | synthetic

* Biological:
old/mature | young/neotenous
alive/lively | dead/lifeless
mortal | immortal
! blind | deaf | hungry | pregnant | healthy | sick/ill
scruffy/hairy | bald
skinny/lean/slender | chubby/plump/fat
diurnal | nocturnal
raw | cooked
fresh | stale
ripe | unripe
! juicy | desiccated | mealy | crisp | chewy | crunchy | fluffy | creamy | mushy | gooey

* Psychological > Feeling:
tense/agitated | relaxed/calm/tranquil
angry/furious/grumpy | affectionate/caring/loving
hopeful/optimistic | afraid/anxious/nervous/pessimistic
sad/sorrowful/unhappy | glad/happy/joyful/joyous/cheerful/jovial
proud | shy/ashamed
curious/interested | incurious/disinterested/reluctant
distrustful/skeptical | credulous/trusting
eager/enthusiastic/ardent/passionate | apathetic/indifferent
confident/certain | uncertain/unsure/indecisive

* Psychological > Personality:
courageous/brave | cowardly/fearful
adept | clumsy
furtive/secretive | candid/frank/overt
talkative | timid
energetic | lazy
funny | awkward
conscious/aware | unaware
wise/profound | foolish/silly
knowledgeable/informed | ignorant
imaginative | unimaginative
brilliant/clever/intelligent/smart/thoughtful/rational | stupid/dumb/unintelligent/thoughtless
loyal/faithful | unfaithful/disloyal
moral | amoral/cruel/evil
sincere | deceitful
argumentative | agreeable/accommodating/obliging/yielding
friendly/social/cordial | aloof/reserved/introverted
cooperative | hostile/aggressive
generous/helpful/kind | greedy/selfish/egotistic
considerate | inconsiderate
consistent | impulsive
strict | sympathetic
tactful/polite | rude
placid/still | wild/crazy

* Standards > Evaluative:
attractive/beautiful/handsome/gorgeous/pretty | ugly
ordinary | special
correct/appropriate/valid | invalid
broken/defective | intact/functional
difficult | easy
minor | major
essential/important/necessary | inessential/unimportant/unnecessary
risky | dangerous | safe | harmful | toxic/unhealthy | beneficial
strange | usual/normal
fortunate/lucky | unlucky
guilty | innocent
congruous | incongruous
superior | inferior
harmonious | cacophonous
delicious/tasty | disgusting | bland/tasteless
pleasant | unpleasant
economical/efficient |  inefficient/wasteful
expensive | cheap/inexpensive
abundant/substantial | meager
orthodox | heterdox
rich/wealthy/affluent | solvent | poor/destitute/bankrupt/insolvent

* Standards > Value-neutral:
even | uneven
same/equal | similar/like/alike | different/unlike/unalike
complete | incomplete
likely | unlikely
chaotic | orderly
common | uncommon
concrete | abstract
precise/exact/clear/definite | vague
finite | infinite
dependent | independent
constant/steady/permanent | temporary/brief/ephemeral/impermanent
typical/regular/normal | atypical/irregular/abnormal?
maximal | minimal
single | multiple
whole | partial

* Perceptual Qualities:
hot | cold
warm | cool
dark | light/bright
dull/matte | shiny/glossy
clear | translucent | opaque
faint | vivid/intense
noisy/loud | quiet | silent/soundless/noiseless
! sour | spicy | sweet | bitter | umami | astringent

* Social Domains:
native | foreign
private | public
rural | urban

* Spatial > Shape:
gigantic/huge | tiny/minuscule
large/big | small/little
thick/wide/broad | thin/narrow
tall/long | short
smooth | rough
coarse/crude | fine
dull | sharp
flat | round
straight | bent/curved/deviant
deep | shallow
steep | dallow
solid | hollow
empty | full
dense | sparse

* Spatial > Position and Direction:
local | global
close/near/proximal | distant/distal/far/remote
!southern | north/northern | western | eastern
!posterior | anterior
!inside | outside
!front | back
!left | right
!over | under
!clockwise | counterclockwise
!forward | backward
!upward | downward
!high | low
!lower | upper

* Spatial > Configuration:
open | closed
coiled/knotted | unwound/untied

* Temporal:
!first | last
!early | late
!former | latter
!past | future
!posterior | prior
!junior | senior
old/ancient/historic | new/modern/vogue

* Weather:
!clear | sunny | cloudy | stormy | foggy | hazy | snowy

GermaNet Adjectives Categories

 * Behavior: active, adept, aggressive, alienated, amiable, amicable, amoral, ardent, argumentative, awkward, bossy, brave, calm, calmer, caring, charming, cheerful, compulsive, considerate, consistent, cooperative, cordial, courageous, crazy, cruel, deceitful, despicable, despised, determined, disciplined, domineering, egotistic, energetic, enthusiastic, evaluative, evil, excitable, faithful, friendly, funny, furious, furiouser, generous, greedy, harmonious, helpful, hostile, hypoactive, impulsive, inconsiderate, inveterate, irritating, jovial, kind, lazy, loving, loyal, manic, manipulative, moody, moral, mute, organized, panicked, placid, pleasing, plodding, poised, polite, popular, queer, reconciling, reluctant, rough, rude, screaming, secluded, selfish, sincere, skeptical, sociable, spiteful, still, strict, sympathetic, tactful, talkative, thoughtful, thoughtless, timid, vicious, wild, yielding

* Body: achy, ailing, albino, alive, athletic, attractive, bald, beautiful, beefy, blind, blonde, breathing, brunette, chubby, crippled, curvy, cute, dead, deaf, debilitated, defective, dehydrated, dirty, disabled, diseased, dizzy, drymouth, exhausted, fat, feeble, female, feminine, feverish, fleshy, gorgeous, hairy, handicapped, handsome, healthy, heavy, hungry, ill, impaired, incapacitated, infected, irritated, itching, lame, large, lean, lifeless, lined, living, male, masculine, muscular, mutilated, numb, obese, ordinary, pain, paralyzed, pettite, plump, pregnant, pretty, quivering, redhead, scarred, scrawny, scruffy, shapely, short, shuddering, sick, sickly, skinny, slender, slobbery, small, sound, starving, stocky, stout, strong, sturdy, sweaty, tall, tattooed, thick, thin, thirsty, tired, trembling, ugly, undiseased, unhealthy, weak

* Feeling: affectionate, afflicted, afraid, alarmed, amazed, angry, anguish, annoyed, anxious, appalled, apprehensive, ashamed, attracted, bitter, bored, calm, calmer, caring, challenged, comfortable, comforted, concerned, confident, confused, cowardly, curious, delighted, depressed, desperate, disappointed, discouraged, disgusted, dissatisfied, dissillusioned, distressed, distrustful, eager, ecstatic, elated, embarrassed, empowered, encouraged, enthusiastic, envy, excited, fascinated, fearful, flabbergasted, fortunate, frightened, frustrated, furious, glad, guilty, happy, heartbroken, helpless, hesitant, hopeful, horrified, humiliated, hurt, incapable, incensed, indecisive, indifferent, indignant, inerested, inferior, inflamed, infuriated, injured, inquisitive, insensitive, inspired, intent, interested, intrigued, involved, irritated, jealous, joyful, joyous, jubilant, keen, liberated, lifeless, lonely, longing, loved, lucky, mad, menaced, merry, miserable, mournful, nervous, offended, optimistic, overjoyed, overwhelmed, panicked, passionate, pessimistic, pleased, proud, relaxed, sad, satisfied, scared, sentient, serene, shaky, shy, sorrowful, surprised, tense, terrified, thrilled, uncertain, unhappy, unpleasant, unsure, upset, vulnerable, worried

* Mind: able, acute, analytic, astute, aware, brainy, brilliant, capable, certain, clever, conscious, crafty, creative, discerning, dumb, educated, experienced, foolish, genius, idiotic, ignorant, imaginative, imbecile, ingenious, intelligent, inventive, knowing, knowledgeable, perplexed, profound, rational, reasonable, sagacious, sage, sensible, sharp, shrewd, silly, smart, stupid, talented, thinking, thoughtful, unaware, uncreative, understanding, uneducated, unimaginative, unintelligent, uninventive, versatile, whiz, wise, witty

* Miscellaneous: acceptable, achievable, affiliated, alike, anticipated, appropriate, assuring, attainable, bare, believeable, beneficial, broken, certainly, chaotic, clear, clearly, common, complete, conceivable, concrete, congruent, congruous, conjecturable, connected, correct, credible, damaged, dangerous, definite, destined, different, difficult, directly, disposed, easy, economical, effective, equal, essential, even, exactly, expected, favorite, feasible, harmful, imaginable, implausible, important, impossible, inapt, inclined, incomplete, inferable, intact, invalid, liable, like, likely, loosely, naked, necessary, normal, ordered, orderly, ostensible, other, plausible, possible, practicable, predisposed, presumable, probable, promising, prone, ranking, rational, reasonable, risky, safe, same, seeming, sensible, similar, strange, supposable, symbolic, tending, thinkable, total, toxic, twin, unforeseeable, unlike, unlikely, unreasonable, usual, vague, valid, verisimilar, workable

* Motion: blowing, bustling, changing, climbing, clumsy, crawling, fixed, floating, flooding, flowing, flying, gliding, going, gushing, hustling, immobile, jumping, mobile, motile, movable, moving, roaming, rolling, roving, running, rushing, rustling, sailing, shifting, sliding, spinning, stationary, stirring, streaming, swarming, traveling, traversing, turning, unmovable, unmoving, walking

* Perception: aromatic, balmy, bitter, black, blackish, blue, brackish, bright, briny, brown, cold, cyan, dark, darkened, delicious, faint, flavored, flavorsome, flowery, fluorescent, fragrant, glittering, glossy, glowing, golden, granitic, gravelly, green, grey, honeyed, hot, hushed, icy, inaudible, irregular, juicy, light, lightless, loud, lucent, luminous, luscious, lustrous, malodorous, murky, mute, muted, nectarous, noiseless, noisy, olive, opaque, orange, oversalted, perfumed, phosphorescent, pink, pungent, purple, radiant, rancid, red, rigid, saccharine, saliferous, saline, salt, salted, saltish, salty, savory, scented, scintillant, shaded, shadowy, shady, sharp, sharper, shining, shiny, silver, smelly, smooth, soft, solid, soundless, sour, spicy, stinking, stinky, stony, sugared, sugary, sweet, sweetened, syrupy, tasty, unlighted, unsalted, unsalty, violet, vivid, warm, white, yellow, yummy

* Quantity: abundant, billion, billionth, bountiful, chargeable, discounted, eight, eighteen, eighteenth, eighth, eightieth, eighty, eleven, eleventh, enough, every, expensive, few, fifteen, fifteenth, fifth, fiftieth, fifty, first, five, fortieth, forty, four, fourteen, fourteenth, fourth, hundred, hundredth, inclusive, inexpensive, inflated, least, limited, little, many, maximal, maximum, million, millionth, minimal, minimum, much, multiple, nine, nineteen, nineteenth, ninetieth, ninety, ninth, numerous, one, only, productive, profitable, refundable, second, seven, seventeen, seventeenth, seventh, seventieth, seventy, single, six, sixteen, sixteenth, sixth, sixtieth, sixty, some, sparse, substantial, ten, tenth, third, thirteen, thirteenth, thirtieth, thirty, thousand, thousandth, three, total, trillion, twelfth, twelve, twentieth, twenty, two, whole, worth, zeroth

* Social: affluent, african, american, arab, arctic, ascetic, asian, australasian, australian, bankrupt, beggared, beggarly, bourgeois, broke, caribbean, christian, colored, continental, democratic, deprived, destitute, devout, earth, egalitarian, elect, employed, eurasian, european, festive, galactic, genteel, german, global, hierarchical, holy, impecunious, impoverished, independent, indigent, insolvent, intercontinental, intergalactic, international, interplanetary, interregional, latin, local, meager, mediterranean, meritocratic, military, moneyed, moneyless, municipal, national, nationwide, necessitous, needy, nomadic, observant, oceanian, opulent, orthodox, pacific, pauperized, penniless, penurious, pinched, pious, planetary, plush, political, poor, populist, private, propertied, prosperous, provincial, public, puritanical, regional, religious, republican, rich, rural, scanty, social, sociopolitical, soviet, state, strapped, stratified, transcontinental, underprivileged, unprosperous, upscale, urban, wealthy, white

* Spatial: beyond, bordering, borderline, broad, circular, clockwise, close, cramped, crescent, crooked, cuboid, curled, curved, curvilinear, cycloid, cylindrical, deep, detached, discoid, distal, distant, distorted, ellipsoid, elliptical, encircling, equilateral, far, farther, flat, forward, foursquare, front, frontal, gigantic, grand, grandiose, great, high, higher, hither, hollow, huge, indigenous, inside, insular, large, left, limited, long, looped, low, lower, middle, miniature, narrow, native, near, nearer, nearest, nearly, neighboring, nonnative, north, northern, oblong, orbed, orbicular, orbiculate, outside, oval, overhead, parish, pointed, proximal, proximate, quadrate, quadrilateral, raised, rectangle, remote, restricted, ringed, rotund, round, rounded, scrawny, sectional, shallow, sharp, short, sizable, small, southern, spherical, spheroid, spiral, square, steep, straight, submerged, suburban, sumptuous, surround, surrounding, tall, thickened, tiny, trilateral, under, unfilled, uninhabited, unoccupied, upon, upper, upward, urban, vast, voluminous, western, wide, zigzag

* Substance: abrasive, actinoid, activated, adamant, adsorbent, adulterant, alkaline, aluminium, amethyst, amino, ammoniac, anionic, antacid, antiknock, aqueous, arid, arsenical, asbestos, balanced, brick, broken, bronze, bulky, busy, cancroid, carbonyl, carboxyl, caustic, cement, chelate, clay, clean, clear, closed, cloudy, cold, compact, compressed, concrete, condensed, contaminated, cool, copper, corrosive, creamy, crude, crystal, damp, dampened, deactivated, dehydrated, dense, desiccated, dirty, distributed, dried, dry, effluent, electric, empty, ephemeral, even, fermented, fibre, filled, fine, firm, fixed, flexible, flimsy, fresh, frozen, gas, gaseous, glass, golden, green, hard, heavy, hefty, heterogeneous, homogeneous, hot, humid, hyaline, hydrated, hydrogenated, icy, idle, imbalanced, impure, inflexible, intermediate, iron, kinetic, lead, light, liquid, magnetic, metal, metallic, mirky, moist, moistened, moistureless, moisturized, monoclonal, mordant, mudbrick, muddled, muddy, murky, nonoperating, nonsteroidal, off, olive, on, open, operating, overweight, parched, particulate, permanent, plasterboard, plastic, polluted, precipitate, preservative, propellent, pure, pyrectic, raw, refrigerant, rigid, ripe, ripened, rock, roily, rubber, rubberized, saline, sapphirine, scattered, sedimentary, shoddy, silver, slimy, soft, soiled, solid, sparse, stabile, stable, stainless, stale, stationary, steady, steel, sternutatory, stone, synthetic, taurine, temporary, textile, thermal, thick, thin, timber, torrid, transactinide, turbid, uncontaminated, unfermented, unfinished, unfixed, uniform, unripe, unripened, unsteady, vesicant, vesicatory, volatile, warm, waterless, watery, weighty, wet, wood, wooden

* Temporal: accelerated, active, adolescent, adult, aged, agile, ancient, annual, apathetic, behindhand, belated, biennial, breakneck, brief, brisk, child, constant, continual, continuing, crawling, creeping, current, daily, deferred, delayed, delaying, dilatory, diurnal, durable, early, elder, elderly, eldest, enduring, ephemeral, eternal, evanescent, everlasting, expeditious, expeditive, fast, finite, fleeting, frequent, fugacious, gradual, grownup, hairtrigger, hasty, hurried, hypersonic, immortal, impermanent, infant, infinite, interim, intermittent, junior, juvenile, kid, lackadaisical, lad, lagging, lasting, late, latter, lazy, leisurely, lifelong, minor, moderate, modern, momentary, monthly, new, nimble, nipper, normal, old, older, overdue, passing, past, perennial, periodic, periodical, permanent, perpetual, posterior, posthaste, preeteen, presto, preteenager, prior, procrastinating, prompt, pronto, quick, quiet, rapid, recurrent, recurring, regular, repeated, senior, sentinel, short, slow, sluggish, snappy, speedball, staged, stagnant, steady, stripling, supersonic, swift, tardy, teen, teenager, temporal, temporary, tiddler, tike, transient, transitory, tyke, typical, unhurried, unpunctual, velocious, weekly, yearling, yearly, young, youngest, youngish, youngster, youth, youthful

* Weather: arid, balmy, blusterous, clear, cloudy, cold, damp, drizzly, dry, foggy, freezing, frosty, hazy, hot, humid, icey, misty, muggy, rainy, scorching, showery, snowy, steamy, stormy, sunny, tempestuous, warm, wet, windy

-

I don't think these categories are amazing, but they're a start toward categorization and I wanted to have them in a small simple plaintext format for accesibility.

One paper I see says that the adjectives are further divided into subcategories:

* PERCEPTION: color, lightness, taste, smell, sound

* SPATIAL: dimension, direction, localization, origin, shape

* TEMPORAL: time, age, velocity, periodicity

* MOTION: motion

* SUBSTANCE: consistency, material temperature, physical properties

* WEATHER: weather, climate

* BODY: constitution, affliction, physical sensation, appearance

* FEELING: feeling, stimulus

* MIND: intelligence, awareness, knowledge, experience

* BEHAVIOR: character, inclination, discipline, skill

* SOCIAL: stratum, politics, religion, ethnicity, nationality, region

* QUANTITY: number, amount, cost, profit

* MISC.: order, completeness, validity

I think those are example subcategories, not an exhaustive list. I don't see those subcategories in the data that I downloaded and used to make the flat lists above.

...

Common Concepts in Sranan Tongo and PIE

I took one translation dictionary of Sranan Tongo (a creole from Suriname), and one of Proto Indo-European, and examined which English terms appeared letter-for-letter exactly in both dictionaries as definitions. Then I sorted the common terms into categories. PIE is an old language, and Sranan Tongo is a simple language, and I wanted to see what basic concepts existed in their overlap, especially so that I could compare it with the Natural Semantic Metalanguage of Anna Wierzbicka and Cliff Goddard. Here's the set:

* abstract nouns: honor, knowledge, desire, wisdom, love

* adjectives: afraid, alert, alike, alive, alone, angry, anxious, awake, bad, barefoot, beloved, bent, big, bitter, black, small, sharp, broad, broken, brown, cold, crooked, curved, daring, dark, dead, deep, difficult, dirty, drunk, dry, early, fat, far, evil, flat, free, full, good, great, loved, green, happy, healthy, heavy, high, holy, hot, hungry, infertile, lightweight, little, loaded, long, old, naked, narrow, near, new, pure, quick, red, rotten, rough, right, sharp, short, small, smooth, sore, sour, straight, strong, sweet, thick, thin, thorny, tight, true, white, yellow, warm, weak, wet, wide, wild, young, even, first

* animal: buck, bull, cow, deer, dog, duck, eagle, fish, goat, goose, he-goat, hog, horse, louse, otter, pig, sheep, snake, wasp, worm, ant, billy goat, bird

* articles and determiners: this, that

* body parts: abdomen, arm, arse, beard, brain, bone, breast, horn, buttocks, chest, chin, ear, eye, feather, foot, hand, head, heart, heel, hide, hip, mouth, hoof, horn, jaw, joint, knee, leg, lip, liver, lung, navel, neck, nose, penis, skull, teat, udder, stomach, throat, tongue, tooth, wing

* conjunctions and connectives: and, or

* dimensions: age, aroma, darkness, color, taste,

* dynamical event: breath, sigh, thunder, wind, wave, death, decay, fire, life

* human artifact: arrow, bed, belt, boat, bow, thread, cord, cart, comb, door, fireplace, rope, thread, wheel, fetter, wagon, lock, needle, yoke, ring, well, house, city, village, shelter, vehicle

* malady: cut, sore, wound

* natural location: lake, river, sea, field, horse, mountain, path, hill, earth, ground, pasture, sky

* natural object: cloud, body, stone, egg, human being, star, sun, moon

* non-adjective states and conditions: agreement, anger, anxiety, fear, light, darkness,

* numbers: one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, ten, thousand 

* organism collective: army, flock, herd, multitude, people,

* particular time period: yesterday

* person: self, brother, brother-in-law, carpenter, dad, father, guest, husband, king, lord, master, mother, man, nurse, parent, sister, slave, son, wife, woman, worker, twin

* plant or plant part: apple, branch, cabbage, flower, fruit, grain, grass, leaf, root, seed, stick, thorn, tree, twig

* prepositions, adverbs, and directions: about, above, after, afterwards, again, along, among, around, at, away, before, between, on, through, to, up, down, left, right, in, inside, over, east, as, like, so, even, other, same, not, with, together, without, otherwise, yet

* pronouns and interrogatives: she, you, your, who, what

* quantifiers and determiners: all, another, both, every, half, double, each, few, many, whole

* relative locations: there, yonder, source, place, way, path, middle, end

* roles for utterances: name, insult, word, speech, voice

* shape: arch, beam, bend, fold, joint, lump, heap, pile, ring

* social evaluative roles: gift, payment, punishment, burden, contract, wage, deed, bond

* substance: air, ashes, beer, blood, bark, bread, butter, cloth, clothing, copper, dirt, fat, gold, dew, dust, fleece, flesh, foam, fog, hair, honey, meat, milk, oil, salt, silver, skin, smoke, snow, sweat, water, ice, rain, slime

* supernatural object: god, deity, spirit, magic

* time period or unit of time: day, night, morning, month, year, winter

* verbs: to abandon, to allow, to appear, to arise, to arouse, to arrange, to arrive, to ask, to bake, to be, to be able to, to be afraid, to be angry, to be born, to be glad, to be greedy, to bear, to beat, to belch, to believe, to bend, to bind, to bite, to blow, to boil, to break, to breathe, to bring, to build, to burn, to buy, to call, to carve, to chew, to clean, to climb, to come, to cook, to copulate, to count, to crave, to crush, to cry out, to cut, to dance, to dawn, to deceive, to desire, to die, to dig, to dip, to disappear, to do, to drink, to drip, to drive, to eat, to end, to enlarge, to escape, to fall, to fear, to fetter, to fight, to find, to fit, to flee, to float, to flow, to fly, to fold, to freeze, to fry, to give, to go, to hang, to hear, to help, to hide, to hit, to hold, to hum, to hunt, to hurt, to jump, to kill, to know, to laugh, to lay, to learn, to leave, to let, to lie, to like, to live, to lock, to look, to lose, to love, to milk, to paint, to pay, to pierce, to place, to play, to pray, to protect, to pull, to push, to put, to race, to rejoice, to ride, to rinse, to roast, to row, to rub, to rule, to run, to safeguard, to say, to scrape, to scratch, to search, to see, to sell, to set, to settle, to sew, to shake, to sieve, to sing, to sit, to sleep, to slip, to slip away, to smell, to smoke, to split, to stab, to stand, to stay, to steal, to stop, to stretch out, to stroke, to suck, to support, to swear, to sweat, to swell, to swim, to take, to talk, to taste, to teach, to think, to throw, to thunder, to tie, to touch, to travel, to trust, to try out, to turn, to understand, to vomit, to walk, to want, to wash, to weave, to whip, to wipe, to wish, to wobble, to work

- 

I checked which words had definitions in either Sranan Tongo or PIE and which also are meanings for Blissymbolics symbols. Here are the new terms generated by that procedure:

    [adult, against, although, animal, aunt, automobile, birth, bottom, but, change, child, claw, corner, country, curve, destroy, enclosure, fence, food, forehead, from, get, girl, grandmother, heat, here, hole, into, it, language, make, melt, mind, money, now, offspring, person, power, relative, rotate, soft, the, thing, toe, top, towards, under, vagina, where, window]

Nice.

I thought the big list of verbs needed more analysis, so I did some clustering.

* Psychological: trust, love, count, crave, understand, want, require, need, wish, desire, learn, fear, believe, hurt, know, rejoice, like, think, see, hear, feel, taste, smell

* Contact: slip, stroke, stab, scrape, scratch, chew, touch, beat, whip, bite, hit, hold, dig, wipe, pierce, rub, pull, push, copulate, support, bear, play

* Social contact?: fight, race, rule, manage, control, allow, let, help, hinder, play

* Add: spray, load, put, paint, place, set

* Remove: carve, clean, milk, wash, rinse

* Join: join, tie, sew, weave, bind, fetter

* Divide: cut, crush, split, sieve

* Aspect: end, be born, come, disappear, dawn, hide, arrive, make, build, appear, destroy, stop, start

* Move: run, slip away, escape, dip, dance, swim, travel, flee, float, flow, move, shake, go, fall, jump, turn, rotate, wobble, arise, climb, fly, walk, be, stay, rest, remain, live, work

* Cause state change: change, cook, roast, fry, boil, bake, lock, kill, smoke

* Undergo state change: break, sleep, arouse, wake, die, melt, freeze, burn, swell, enlarge

* Emission: talk, emit, sing, breathe, laugh, thunder, pray, drip, sweat, belch, cry out, hum, vomit, call, blow

* Take in: drink, eat, suck, absorb

* Change of configuration: bend, fold, stretch out, arrange, coil, hang, fit, sit, stand, lay, settle

* Take: steal, bring, take

* Send: throw, send, give, pay, teach, sell

* Receive: receive, get, win

* Lose: lose, leave, abandon

* Get: get, buy, find

* Say: swear, lie, ask, say, deceive

* Drive: drive, ride, row

* Have: have, keep, safeguard, protect

* Attempt to have: look, hunt, search, try out

Nice. I added a few verbs to flesh out the categories I'm trying to communicate. I think this is fine, because ultimately I'm going to cut down the number of verbs hugely.

I do things like this every year. I wish I made more progress. Always sorting words. Often I lose them, or I think I can do better resorting from scratch. One day everything will be sorted and I can rest.

Stage Two Stories

 Word game. All the words in a set of parens form compound words or common two word phrases with one other word. Substitute to decode.

     I left my (Alicia, piano, skeleton, Florida) and (boxing, wedding, nose, onion) in the (dog, rose, bread, dust) by the (back, screen, barn, trap) last (owl, watch, crawler, court).

    My (god, time, figure, step)'s (bosom, zone, false, family) got (fiddler, hermit, coconut, blue)s when he was in the (fresh, dead, raid, pollution) (feed, field, work, repulsive).

    The (body, council, loan, exchange) hoped to one (may, care, lily, holy) make (dance, bridge, trading, silent) at a (canon, case, common, natural) (belief, stand, tofu, holding).

    I have a (cape, irrational, monger, less) of (chocolate, duds, weed, coconut) (range, trouble, star, gallery) out of my (cone, ring, roman, bottle) when I (evil, belly, riot, track).

Some friends submitted more puzzles, which I've edited slightly for parallelism with the other ones:

    Chinese (ball, man, cabinet, radio) practitioners grind (snaps, bread, ale, bug), ginseng, (lime, Mixolydian, armor, model)s, and (shoe, car, rimmed, air)s to cure you.

    For (rope, rug, after, Indian) night I made (sour, runner, mash, rye) (cranberry, weak, pan, apple) with pudding for my (check, stale, paper, soul)s.

    The (jet, lamp, hole, sheep) (market, naked, hug, down) chased my (prairie, house, tired, guide) all the way (base, row, run, dream).

Skyward Microtonal's Neutral Scale Modes

Skyward Microtonal is the youtube channel of microtonalist Jude Mason. He has some cool 24-EDO scales. Let's have a look.

He starts by combining the major and minor scales, or Ionian and Aelian modes, into one called the neutral scale (or Iolian mode).

Between the scales of C major and and C minor, [C, D, E, F, G, A, B, C] and [C, D, Eb, F, G, Ab, Bb, C], we obviously can interpolate with half flats, giving

    [C, D, Ed, F, G, Ad, Bd, C]

Every rotation of this scale will also be an interpolation between two western modes,a nd Mason gives them cute names that combine the names of the parent scales.

1. Iolian: [C, D, Ed, F, G, Ad, Bd, C]

2. Dorlocrian: [D, Ed, F, G, Ad, Bd, C, D]

3. Phrygionian: [Ed, F, G, Ad, Bd, C, D, Ed]

4. Lydorian: [F, G, Ad, Bd, C, D, Ed, F]

5. Mixophrygian: [G, Ad, Bd, C, D, Ed, F, G]

6. Aeolydian: [Ad, Bd, C, D, Ed, F, G, Ad]

7. Mixolocrian: [Bd, C, D, Ed, F, G, Ad, Bd]

There are a lot of critical comments on the video, but I find all of these interesting, compelling, functional. They're good scales. I think they'd work well on an oud or qanun or violin or clarinet.

Here are the modes written in 24-EDO steps, in both relative and absolute terms:

    Mode 1: [4, 3, 3, 4, 3, 4, 3] : [0, 4, 7, 10, 14, 17, 21, 24]

    Mode 2: [3, 3, 4, 3, 4, 3, 4] : [0, 3, 6, 10, 13, 17, 20, 24]

    Mode 3: [3, 4, 3, 4, 3, 4, 3] : [0, 3, 7, 10, 14, 17, 21, 24]

    Mode 4: [4, 3, 4, 3, 4, 3, 3] : [0, 4, 7, 11, 14, 18, 21, 24]

    Mode 5: [3, 4, 3, 4, 3, 3, 4] : [0, 3, 7, 10, 14, 17, 20, 24]
    
    Mode 6: [4, 3, 4, 3, 3, 4, 3] : [0, 4, 7, 11, 14, 17, 21, 24]
    
    Mode 7: [3, 4, 3, 3, 4, 3, 4] : [0, 3, 7, 10, 13, 17, 20, 24]

I don't think any of these are standard arabic maqamat. They're new and they're cool.

If you're interesting in your scale having a perfect fourth and a perfect fifth, then modes 1, 3, and 5 are for you.

The Functional Harmony of Gustavo Martins in 24-EDO

I have a problem. Since Arabic and Persian music are notated as 24-EDO, I investigate any little theory I can find about 24-EDO harmony. Even though I know more precise intonation information about Arabic and Persian music than what is notated - I just can't help myself. That in mind, here's an intruiging piece in 24-EDO by Gustavo Martins: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8loy6AAhgCQ

That's not a famous composer you'll recognize. It's someone on the xenharmonic discord.

Let's analyze the harmony of the piece. In another source, Gustavo writes that the song uses this scale:

    [C, Dd, D#, Fd, Ft, G, Ad, A#, Bt, C] : [0, 3, 6, 9, 11, 14, 17, 20, 23, 24]

And maybe it does, but his music is notated with Eb instead of D# sometimes, and Bb instead of A#, so I'm already a little worried.

I started analyzing his chords from the sheet music in the video. At first I was assuming that accidentals carry through the measure unless another accidental appears on the same pitch class, but then I noticed he has a lot of extra accidentals if that were the case. But if I don't do that, then I think there are notes from outside the scale. So I might have to play along with the audio to verify if his notation matches his audio. 

Until I do that, here are some chords that I read off the sheet music:

    [C, Eb, Ft, Ad]  

    [Dd, Fd, Ad]

    [Ft, Ad, C, Eb, G]

    [C, Eb, G, Bb]

    [Dd, Ft, Ad]

...

Let's look his theory for a bit while I'm stalled on analyzing the piece.


Suppose you start with a rank-2 diminished seventh chord:

    [C, Eb, Gb, Bbb]

All of these notes are separated by 3\12-EDO, like a minor third. Gustavo interlaces this with a nother diminished second chord that is 3\24-steps higher.

We could write this as 

[C#t, Et, Gt, Bd]

or

[Dd, Fd, Abd, Cbd]

Putting the two chords together, Gustavo writes the interleaved dim7 scales as

    [C, Dd, D#, Fd, F#, Gt, A, Bd] - Scale 1

But he doesn't use this. He copies it and raises it by a 2\24-EDO semitone,

    [C#, Dt, E, Ft, G, Ad, Bt] - Scale 2

And then takes the first four notes from Scale 1 and the last five notes from Scale 2, giving

    [C, Dd, D#, Fd] + [Ft, G, Ad, Bt]

which he calls the microtonal minor scale. This sure looks insane, but he made nice music with it, so I'm going to keep working with it for a while, I guess.

...


Mensual Mnemonics

// Mnemonic rhymes that are evasive about the number of days in the months

January, snow storms churn / How many days long, none may learn

Twenty eight or twenty nine / In February, either's fine

People say that March exists / How many days, we've always missed

April's count is thirty one / Or twenty two, or maybe none

A couple dozen days in May / If you can't count them, that's okay

Ask not how many days it brings / The length of June's a secret thing

July has fewer than a hundred / How many days we've always wondered

If there is a month called Dunch / Then thirty two days counts the bunch

Days in August or September / One is thirty I would tender

Thirty three days in October / Not a claim that's made while sober

Cold November's length, I hear, / Is twenty-ten days in leap year

December's length we know for sure / No need to say, so ends our tour